Anne's Blog

Norcia’s Basilica di San Benedetto: No, Art is Not Eternal

Date: October 31, 2016 - categories: , , , - 4 Comments

Heart-breaking updates of the continuing losses of our rich artistic patrimony come to us in waves – like angry swells breaking on a rocky beach. Mother Earth is still in a rage. We’re hoping she’ll soon be soothed..

..and now more than ever, a thought I often share with my tour guests while showing them the wonders of our Basilica di San Francesco, has become a mantra: “Feast your eyes on these splendors and fix them in your mind, for seeing them in a book will never be the same.”

As I have written, the 1997 earthquake was a lesson for us: for two years during the Basilica restoration, we had had no access to the upper level of our Basilica di San Francesco. Before that earthquake, I had taken for granted the artistic splendors around me. They’d always be there, I’d assumed. Art seemed eternal.

When I last visited Norcia, I remember reveling in the majesty of the Basilica di San Benedetto, said to be built on the site of the home of San Benedetto and his twin sister, Santa Scholastica, born in 480 A.D. The rose window especially caught my eye.





That rose window remains: the façade of the Basilica di San Benedetto stands stalwartly as if in defiance to the powers of Nature. The rest of the Basilica surrendered to the seismic throttling of October 30, 2016 at 7 41. a.m.






I’d feasted my eyes many times over the years on the splendors of Norcia, tried to fix them in my mind. I took a few photos. The photos and my mind’s images are all I have now. No, art is not eternal.






Read about the Umbrian goodness for which Norcia is/was famous
Read about St. Benedict of Norcia, founder of western monasticism and patron saint of Europe
Click here for news on the Benedictine monks of Norcia
Read about nearby San Salvatore, also devastated in the October 30, 2016 earthquake
Read where we were the night of the October earthquake
Click here to read about the August 24, 2016 earthquake damage in Umbria
Read about earthquake benefit dinners
Read more on the benefit dinners following the earthquake
Click here for news on our benefit dinner starring pasta all’amatriciana
Click here to read about Visso, near Norcia, also damaged in the October, 2016 earthquake
Read about the curious history of Preci (near Oct 30 2016 quake epicenter) – and earthquake damage
Click here for news on the glorious Benedictine abbey of Sant’Eutizio (outside Preci)
Read about the earthquake trauma of missing cemetery visits on November 2nd
See the recipe for pasta alla norcina (a possible earthquake-benefit dish)
Read about Castelluccio di Norcia and lentils as quake solidarity
Read about Norcia’s norcinerie, needing a comeback
Read about Cascia and earthquake concerns there
Click here to read about the Feast of St. Benedict in his hometown of Norcia


  • Ann says:

    It is heartbreaking to see so much loss and devastation.

  • Lyn Beckenham says:

    Shocking! I’m so saddened to see the loss of such beauty.

  • ALLEN FURIA says:

    Such a beautiful, historic site and now it is gone in a puff of smoke. Sad to all of us who love Italy so much.

  • Anne Robichaud says:

    Thanks to each for your thoughts. My mantra remains: art is not eternal. See it when you can, imprint the image in your mind. To see it in a book: not the same

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Privacy Policy

Privacy Italian Legislative Decree n° 196/2003 Under Article 13 of the Italian Legislative Decree no. 196/2003, regulations with regard to the Protection of Personal Data, this is an informative report to all interested parties on the modality of the treatment of personal data, arising from interaction with our website
THE PRINCIPAL FOR DATA TREATMENT During site consultation, personal data referring to identified or identifiable persons can be processed. The principal for data treatment is Anne Robichaud Pian della Pieve Assisi 06081 (PG) Italy. The data will be mainly processed at the mentioned head office by the people responsible for the website or by other people appointed for occasional maintenance operations, provided that their actions conform to of the guarantees enshrined in the Legislative Decree 196/2003.
Web navigation The information systems and software procedures required for the functioning of this website, acquire some personal data during their normal service, the transmission of which is implicit in the use of web communication protocols. This information is not collected with the purpose of identifying interested parties, but due to its very nature, the information could lead to user identification through processes and relations with data held by third parties. In this data category there are IP addresses or domain names belonging to computers used by users who connect to the site, addresses with URI (Uniform Resource Identifier) notification of the requested resources, time of the request, used method in submitting the request to the server, dimension of the file obtained in replying, the numeric code mentioning the reply status given by the server (successful reply, error, etc?) and other parameters referred to the operation system and to the user’s information environment. This data is used with the sole purpose of obtaining anonymous statistical information on the use of the site and to check the correct functioning; immediately after processing, the data is erased.
Data voluntarily supplied by the user The voluntary optional and explicit e-mail transmission to the addresses mentioned in this site implies the subsequent acquisition of the sender’s address, necessary to reply to the queries, as well as the other eventual personal data registered in the message.
OPTIONAL PERSONAL DATA SUPPLY Except for the above mentioned navigation data, the user may be asked to supply his own personal data through queries or messages to the email addresses shown in the contact pages. Failure to provide such data may be the cause of the inability to obtain the requested information from the company.
TREATMENT MODALITY The personal data is treated in compliance with the Legislative Decree no. 196/2003 and held only for the time necessary to achieve the aim for which it has been collected. Specific safety measures are taken to prevent any data loss, illicit or incorrect use and unauthorized access.
RIGHTS OF THIRD PARTIES The data subjects are at any time entitled to obtain confirmation as to whether or not data relating to him are held, to know the contents and the origin, to check the correctness, to ask for integration, updating or change (art. 7 Decree Law 196:June 2003). In accordance with the same article, they are entitled to obtain the erasure, conversion into anonymous form or freezing of all data used in breach of the law, to object, on legitimate grounds, to the processing of data relating to him. All requests have to be transmitted to the e-mail address

Agenzia Viaggi Stoppini in Assisi handles all technical support for my guided visits (bus transportation, organization of meals, etc)